Principle 08 of 8
Responsibility
Workers, suppliers, communities, competitors, and the environment count too.
Protects
Workers, suppliers, communities, competitors, the environment
Why it matters
A business can be honest with every customer and still do harm to the people who make its products, the market it competes in, or the place it operates.
Covers
Worker and workplace conduct (Category 11), anti-competitive behavior (Category 12), supply chains (Category 13), and environmental conduct (Category 14).
Practices that break it
53 subsections · 285 practices
4.6Worker / Workplace Surveillance+ Privacy7
6.3Algorithmic Wage & Earnings Manipulation+ Fairness4
7.3Greenwashing & Sustainability Misrepresentation+ Honesty10
8.2Planned Obsolescence+ Safety5
9.7Cultural Appropriation & Disrespect+ Fairness6
9.8Indigenous Rights Violations+ Fairness4
10.7Migrant & Visa-Dependent Coercion+ Care5
10.8Incarcerated Population Exploitation+ Care6
11.1Worker Misclassification+ Fairness5
11.2Wage Theft9
11.3Unpaid Overtime & Crunch5
11.4Benefits Denial4
11.5Schedule Instability & Algorithmic Scheduling3
11.6Hazardous Conditions & PPE+ Safety11
11.7Safety Incident Underreporting+ Safety6
11.8Retaliation Against Reporting+ Accountability4
11.9Non-Compete Overreach+ Autonomy4
11.10Forced Labor & Child Labor in Operations4
11.11Mass Layoffs After Profit & Disposable Workforce4
11.12Performance & Quality Management Abuse+ Care3
11.13Pay Disparity & Discrimination+ Fairness2
11.14Moderator & Worker Trauma+ Care5
11.15Unpaid Labor & Career-Path Exploitation8
11.16Restrictions on Career Mobility+ Autonomy4
12.1Predatory Pricing & Cross-Subsidy2
12.2Acquisitions to Kill Competition4
12.3Self-Preferencing on Owned Platforms+ Honesty6
12.4Tying & Forced Bundling+ Autonomy4
12.5Exclusive Dealing & Foreclosure4
12.6Bid Rigging & Collusion6
12.7Monopoly Rent Extraction+ Fairness7
12.8Open-Source / Standards Manipulation9
12.9Merchant / Seller Exploitation+ Fairness4
13.1Supply Chain Opacity+ Honesty7
13.2Forced & Child Labor in Supply Chain9
13.3Animal Cruelty in Supply Chain4
13.4Counterfeit & Sanctioned Goods+ Honesty4
13.5Deforestation-Linked Sourcing2
13.6Supplier Squeeze & Contract Abuse+ Fairness3
14.1Emission Underreporting & Concealment+ Honesty8
14.2Carbon-Offset Greenwashing+ Honesty5
14.3Pollution Concealment+ Honesty10
14.4Environmental Justice Siting+ Fairness3
14.5Habitat & Ecosystem Destruction9
14.6Microplastics & Persistent Pollutants6
14.7E-Waste & Disposal8
14.8Pesticide & Antibiotic Overuse4
14.9Site Abandonment & Stranded Liabilities+ Accountability6
14.10Catastrophic Risk Concealment+ Safety5
14.11Lobbying Against Environmental Regulation+ Accountability7
14.12Resource Hoarding3
15.1Whistleblower Suppression+ Accountability4
15.9Strategic Bankruptcy & Corporate Restructuring+ Accountability4
The same principle, across industries
Every practice above, as it reads in the catalog. Numbers link to the standard.
4.6 Worker / Workplace Surveillance · 7 practices
Responsibility+ Privacy
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.6.1 | Keystroke / Screen Monitoring | Recording keystrokes, screenshots, or screen contents continuously or at random intervals without meaningful notice. | Internal company ethics, surveillance technology, staffing/temp agencies |
| 4.6.2 | Behavioral Analytics on Staff | Using AI to analyze employee communication patterns, tone, sentiment, or social graph to score, rank, or flag workers. | Internal company ethics, HR |
| 4.6.3 | Productivity Score Quantification | Assigning numerical scores based on mouse movement, idle time, or app switching, then using them in performance, termination, or promotion decisions. | Internal company ethics, surveillance technology |
| 4.6.4 | Covert Meeting Recording | Recording, transcribing, or analyzing internal meetings or calls without the contemporaneous knowledge of all participants. | Internal company ethics |
| 4.6.5 | Personal-Device MDM Intrusion | Requiring monitoring or MDM software on personally owned devices as a condition of employment. | Internal company ethics |
| 4.6.6 | Union-Busting Surveillance | Tools or services designed to identify, track, or undermine labor organizing. | Surveillance technology |
| 4.6.7 | AI-Driven Worker Monitoring | Tracking keystrokes, bathroom breaks, movement, or productivity to create constant surveillance environments. | AI vendors, warehousing, call centers, ride-hailing, food delivery |
6.3 Algorithmic Wage & Earnings Manipulation · 4 practices
Responsibility+ Fairness
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6.3.1 | Algorithmic Pay Adjustment | Using opaque algorithms to adjust per-task pay based on predicted worker acceptance, systematically suppressing earnings. | Ride-hailing, food delivery, freelance/gig |
| 6.3.2 | Surge / Demand Capture | Implementing surge pricing where the platform captures a disproportionate share of the increase rather than passing it to workers. | Ride-hailing, freelance |
| 6.3.3 | Behavioral-Nudge Penalties | Designing penalty structures (acceptance rate, response time) that coerce workers into unsafe or undesirable conditions. | Gig economy, ride-hailing, food delivery |
| 6.3.4 | Opaque Worker Reliability Scores | Internal performance/reliability scores that gate placement opportunities without disclosed criteria or appeal. | Staffing/temp, gig economy, freelance |
7.3 Greenwashing & Sustainability Misrepresentation · 10 practices
Responsibility+ Honesty
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7.3.1 | Vague Eco Claims | Marketing products as "natural," "clean," "eco-friendly," "sustainable," or "non-toxic" without standardized definitions or verification. | Beauty, food, fashion, baby products, cleaning, personal care |
| 7.3.2 | Carbon-Offset Greenwashing | Claiming carbon neutrality through low-quality, non-additional, or unverifiable offsets while absolute emissions continue to rise. | AI, crypto, airlines, oil/gas, logistics, shipping, travel |
| 7.3.3 | REC / Renewable Double-Counting | Counting the same renewable certificates toward both regulatory compliance and voluntary customer claims. | Energy utilities, renewable energy, crypto |
| 7.3.4 | Greenhouse-Pledge Without Plan | Announcing distant net-zero or sustainability targets without interim milestones, accountability, or capital allocation. | Renewable energy, oil/gas, food manufacturing |
| 7.3.5 | Deadstock Destruction | Incinerating or landfilling unsold inventory to protect brand prestige, while marketing sustainability. | Fashion, luxury goods |
| 7.3.6 | Recycling Program Greenwashing | Promoting take-back, refill, or recycling programs that divert minimal waste while claiming environmental leadership. | Beauty, home appliances, e-commerce, waste management |
| 7.3.7 | Process-Claim Inflation | Marketing as "artisanal," "small-batch," or "handcrafted" without defined standards or third-party verification. | Food, alcohol, beauty |
| 7.3.8 | Certification Logo Misuse | Displaying certifications (organic, non-GMO, humane, fair-trade) that have lapsed, are scoped narrowly, or come from shell certifiers. | Food, agriculture, beauty |
| 7.3.9 | Energy-Rating Manipulation | Configuring devices for testing conditions that do not reflect real-world energy consumption. | Home appliances, automotive |
| 7.3.10 | Cruelty-Free Misrepresentation | Using cruelty-free claims without independent verification, or selling in markets that require animal testing while claiming cruelty-free elsewhere. | Beauty, personal care |
8.2 Planned Obsolescence · 5 practices
Responsibility+ Safety
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8.2.1 | Limited-Lifespan Design | Engineering products with intentionally shortened lifespans through material or component choices. | Home appliances, electronics, consumer goods |
| 8.2.2 | Software-Driven Slowdown | Withholding firmware updates or intentionally slowing devices via software to render hardware obsolete. | Home appliances, smartphones |
| 8.2.3 | Feature Removal via OTA | Remotely removing or degrading features the customer already purchased. | Automotive, smart appliances, gaming |
| 8.2.4 | Cosmetic Redesign Obsolescence | Releasing cosmetic updates that render accessories, cases, or peripherals incompatible. | Home appliances, smartphones |
| 8.2.5 | Implantable / Critical-Device Lifespan Limits | Designing implantable or critical devices with unnecessarily limited lifespans. | Healthcare (medical devices) |
9.7 Cultural Appropriation & Disrespect · 6 practices
Responsibility+ Fairness
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9.7.1 | Cultural Appropriation in Branding | Co-opting traditional practices, designs, or aesthetics from marginalized communities without attribution or compensation. | Beauty, fashion, film/television, travel |
| 9.7.2 | Religious Accommodation Failure | Failing to accommodate religious, cultural, or spiritual practices in service delivery, or actively obstructing them. | Funeral services, healthcare |
| 9.7.3 | Cultural-Practice Disrespect | Dismissing, ridiculing, or refusing to accommodate culturally specific mourning, body-preparation, or disposition preferences. | Funeral & death care |
| 9.7.4 | Sacred-Site Tourism Without Consent | Operating tours to indigenous or sacred sites without community permission or benefit sharing. | Travel/tourism |
| 9.7.5 | Cultural Commodification | Packaging sacred ceremonies, traditional dress, or rituals as entertainment for tourists. | Travel/tourism |
| 9.7.6 | Indigent Burial Neglect | Providing minimal or disrespectful services for indigent or unclaimed remains. | Funeral & death care |
9.8 Indigenous Rights Violations · 4 practices
Responsibility+ Fairness
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9.8.1 | FPIC Violation | Proceeding with extraction, infrastructure, or development on indigenous lands without free, prior, and informed consent. | Mining, oil/gas, renewable energy |
| 9.8.2 | Cultural Heritage Destruction | Destroying or desecrating cultural and archaeological sites during extraction or development. | Mining, construction |
| 9.8.3 | Forced Displacement | Acquiring land through coercion, inadequate compensation, or legal pressure to displace communities. | Oil/gas, mining, real estate, renewable energy |
| 9.8.4 | Community Benefit Agreement Failure | Failing to deliver promised community investments, jobs, or infrastructure after project approval. | Renewable energy, oil/gas, mining, public transit, waste management |
10.7 Migrant & Visa-Dependent Coercion · 5 practices
Responsibility+ Care
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10.7.1 | Visa-Dependent Worker Coercion | Recruiting workers under temporary visas with housing deductions, restricted mobility, or deportation threats if they complain. | Hospitality, agriculture, travel/tourism, defense |
| 10.7.2 | Document Confiscation | Confiscating documents, charging recruitment fees, or imposing terms that leave workers indebted. | Construction, agriculture, seafood |
| 10.7.3 | H1-B Cost-Arbitrage Staffing | Structuring staffing around visa-dependent workers unable to negotiate or leave. | Consulting |
| 10.7.4 | Undocumented Worker Threats | Employing undocumented workers at below-market wages with deportation threats if they report safety violations or wage theft. | Construction, home services |
| 10.7.5 | Migrant Recruitment-Fee Brokering | Hiring through labor brokers who charge fees, withhold wages, or impose contracts that create indebtedness. | Seafood, agriculture, construction |
10.8 Incarcerated Population Exploitation · 6 practices
Responsibility+ Care
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10.8.1 | Inmate Communication Cost Gouging | Charging far-above-market rates for phone, video, and messaging through exclusive provider contracts. | Prison/corrections |
| 10.8.2 | Commissary Price Inflation | Marking up essential goods (hygiene, food, clothing) above retail within facilities. | Prison/corrections |
| 10.8.3 | Forced Labor Below Minimum Wage | Assigning incarcerated workers to jobs paying far below minimum wage under threat of disciplinary action. | Prison/corrections |
| 10.8.4 | Inmate Medical Care Denial | Systematically understaffing medical units, delaying treatment, or denying specialist referrals. | Prison/corrections |
| 10.8.5 | Inmate Medication Cost Inflation | Charging above-market prices for prescriptions or substituting cheaper medications without clinical equivalence. | Prison/corrections |
| 10.8.6 | Family Location Tracking via Inmate Metadata | Using communication metadata to surveil, locate, or profile family members outside the facility. | Prison/corrections |
11.1 Worker Misclassification · 5 practices
Responsibility+ Fairness
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.1.1 | Forced Contractor Status | Classifying workers as independent contractors when the role meets the legal definition of employment. | Ride-hailing, food delivery, gig economy, cleaning, construction, plumbing, home services, logistics, gaming, oil/gas, waste management, wedding |
| 11.1.2 | Permanent-Temp Classification | Assigning workers to indefinite temporary or contract status to avoid benefits and protections. | Staffing/temp agencies, gaming |
| 11.1.3 | Perma-Lancer Loops | Cycling workers through successive contract terms or agencies to prevent conversion to permanent. | Staffing/temp |
| 11.1.4 | Misclassification Feedback Loop | Using industry-wide misclassification as a benchmark, pressuring competitors to follow. | Gig economy |
| 11.1.5 | Buyout-Fee Suppression | Setting prohibitively high temp-to-perm conversion fees to discourage clients from hiring directly. | Staffing/temp |
11.2 Wage Theft · 9 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.2.1 | Off-the-Clock Work | Requiring setup, travel, or cleanup tasks without pay. | Cleaning, construction, plumbing, retail |
| 11.2.2 | Tip Appropriation | Redirecting customer tips to base pay or platform fees rather than passing them to workers. | Food delivery, ride-hailing, hospitality |
| 11.2.3 | Tip Withholding | Collecting mandatory gratuities from clients but not distributing full amounts to staff. | Wedding planning, hospitality |
| 11.2.4 | Tip-Credit Exploitation | Using tip-credit provisions to pay below minimum wage while assigning non-tipped duties that dilute tip income. | Hospitality, travel/tourism |
| 11.2.5 | Markup Wage Theft | Charging clients significantly more than worker pay rate while concealing markup, appropriating earned wages. | Staffing/temp agencies |
| 11.2.6 | Piece-Rate Sub-Minimum-Wage | Setting piece-rate or per-job pay at levels resulting in sub-minimum-wage earnings for typical work speed. | Plumbing, agriculture, gig economy |
| 11.2.7 | Hidden Deductions | Subtracting uniform, background-check, training, or admin costs from paychecks without clear disclosure. | Staffing/temp |
| 11.2.8 | Wage Theft on Public Projects | Failing to pay prevailing wages, withholding final paychecks, or unauthorized deductions on taxpayer-funded projects. | Construction |
| 11.2.9 | Stream-Threshold Wage Theft | Withholding payment for streams below an arbitrary minimum threshold, pocketing revenue from millions of micro-plays by smaller artists. | Music industry |
11.3 Unpaid Overtime & Crunch · 5 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.3.1 | Overtime Denial | Requiring schedules above 40 hours while refusing overtime compensation. | Cleaning, construction, hospitality |
| 11.3.2 | Crunch Culture | Sustaining mandatory or culturally expected 60–100+ hour weeks for months before launch. | Gaming |
| 11.3.3 | Up-or-Out Burnout | Maintaining promotion systems that demand unsustainable hours, normalizing burnout. | Consulting, finance, law |
| 11.3.4 | Burnout-Industry Norm | Normalizing excessive hours, constant availability, and weekend work as industry expectations. | PR/marketing, consulting |
| 11.3.5 | Forced Dispatch / Coerced Driving | Pressuring drivers to operate beyond legal hours-of-service through dispatch practices. | Shipping/freight |
11.4 Benefits Denial · 4 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.4.1 | Benefits Denial Through Misclassification | Structuring engagements to avoid health insurance, retirement, or paid leave. | Gig economy, ride-hailing, food delivery, freelance, staffing/temp |
| 11.4.2 | Benefits Two-Tier Denial | Excluding temp or contract workers from benefits available to permanent employees. | Staffing/temp |
| 11.4.3 | Benefit Stripping Post-Acquisition | Eliminating or reducing healthcare, retirement, or other benefits after acquiring portfolio companies. | Private equity |
| 11.4.4 | Pension Fund Underfunding | Reducing or suspending employer pension contributions to improve cash flow before exit. | Private equity |
11.5 Schedule Instability & Algorithmic Scheduling · 3 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.5.1 | On-Call / Just-in-Time Scheduling | Publishing schedules with minimal notice, split shifts, or on-call requirements that prevent second jobs or childcare. | Hospitality, retail, fast food |
| 11.5.2 | Algorithmic Schedule Instability | Assigning unpredictable schedules that prevent financial or personal planning. | Gig economy, food delivery |
| 11.5.3 | Scheduling Practices Suppressing Wages | Schedules designed to keep workers below full-time hours or prevent reliable second employment. | Grocery, retail |
11.6 Hazardous Conditions & PPE · 11 practices
Responsibility+ Safety
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.6.1 | PPE Cost Shifting to Workers | Requiring workers to purchase their own respirators, gloves, or protective clothing. | Cleaning, agriculture, pest control, chemical manufacturing |
| 11.6.2 | Hazardous Condition Exposure | Failing to provide protective equipment, shade, ventilation, or safe conditions for high-risk work. | Agriculture, cleaning, construction, mining |
| 11.6.3 | Chemical Exposure Non-Disclosure | Failing to inform workers about specific chemicals, exposure levels, or known health risks. | Chemical manufacturing, oil/gas, cleaning, pest control |
| 11.6.4 | Reproductive-Hazard Concealment | Failing to warn workers of documented reproductive hazards (mutagens, teratogens, endocrine disruptors). | Chemical manufacturing |
| 11.6.5 | Cancer-Cluster Non-Investigation | Declining to investigate or acknowledge elevated cancer rates among workers when internal data suggests facility-related causation. | Chemical manufacturing |
| 11.6.6 | Heat / Fatigue Risk Neglect | Assigning extended outdoor or extreme-temperature shifts without mandated rest or hydration. | Staffing/temp, agriculture, waste management |
| 11.6.7 | Black-Lung / Dust-Exposure Concealment | Suppressing or manipulating dust exposure data to avoid implementing required controls. | Mining |
| 11.6.8 | Fatigue-Risk Normalization | Scheduling that creates chronic fatigue in safety-critical operations without mitigation. | Oil/gas, airlines, transit, shipping |
| 11.6.9 | Pressure to Speed Causing Unsafe Driving | Unrealistic delivery time estimates and late-arrival penalties that incentivize reckless driving. | Food delivery, ride-hailing, shipping |
| 11.6.10 | Production Quotas Compromising Safety | Pick-and-pack or daily-job quotas that force workers to skip breaks or compromise safety. | Logistics, warehousing, pest control, shipping |
| 11.6.11 | Housekeeper Workload | Excessive room counts per shift with piece-rate pay that incentivizes skipping safety protocols. | Hospitality |
11.7 Safety Incident Underreporting · 6 practices
Responsibility+ Safety
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.7.1 | OSHA Violation Concealment | Hiding or failing to report workplace injuries, OSHA violations, or hazardous conditions. | Construction, oil/gas |
| 11.7.2 | Injury Reporting Discouragement | Discouraging temp/contractor injury reporting through retaliation or quota penalties. | Staffing/temp, logistics, warehousing |
| 11.7.3 | Contractor-Labor Risk Shifting | Using contracted labor for the most hazardous operations to avoid direct employer liability and long-term health monitoring. | Oil/gas, mining, chemical manufacturing |
| 11.7.4 | Inadequate Worker Insurance | Providing minimal or no accident insurance for workers while on the job. | Food delivery, gig economy |
| 11.7.5 | Detention-Time Unpaid | Failing to compensate drivers for extended wait times at facilities beyond their control. | Shipping/freight |
| 11.7.6 | Equipment Injury Training Absence | Not training workers on safe operation of industrial cleaning, construction, or warehouse equipment. | Cleaning, construction |
11.8 Retaliation Against Reporting · 4 practices
Responsibility+ Accountability
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.8.1 | Retaliation Against Workers Reporting Safety | Penalizing workers who report safety violations through reduced hours, termination, or blacklisting. | Cleaning, childcare, construction, hospitality |
| 11.8.2 | Whistleblower Retaliation | Demoting, terminating, blacklisting, or otherwise retaliating against employees who report fraud, safety failures, or unethical practices. | Internal company ethics, defense, government, mining, accounting, healthcare, pharma |
| 11.8.3 | Security-Clearance Coercion | Using security-clearance requirements to suppress employee complaints or limit job mobility. | Defense |
| 11.8.4 | NDAs Silencing Misconduct | Using NDAs or separation agreements to prevent employees from speaking publicly about unethical practices, surveillance, or safety concerns. | Internal company ethics, consulting, PR/marketing |
11.9 Non-Compete Overreach · 4 practices
Responsibility+ Autonomy
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.9.1 | Overbroad Non-Compete | Imposing non-compete clauses that restrict career mobility beyond legitimate business interests. | Consulting, gaming, legal, music, mental health |
| 11.9.2 | Non-Compete on Low-Wage Workers | Imposing non-competes on hourly or low-wage workers to suppress turnover. | Private equity portfolio, staffing/temp |
| 11.9.3 | Multi-App Penalty | Penalizing or deactivating gig workers who work for competing platforms. | Food delivery, ride-hailing |
| 11.9.4 | Therapist Non-Compete | Enforcing non-competes that prevent therapists from continuing care with patients after leaving a platform. | Mental health |
11.10 Forced Labor & Child Labor in Operations · 4 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.10.1 | Forced Labor on Vessels / Sites | Using debt bondage, confiscated documents, or coercion to retain workers without freedom to leave. | Seafood, agriculture, hospitality |
| 11.10.2 | At-Sea / Remote Worker Abuse Concealment | Physical violence, food withholding, or confinement of workers far from oversight. | Seafood |
| 11.10.3 | Isolation as Intimidation | Deliberately keeping workers in remote settings to prevent contact with authorities or complaint filing. | Seafood |
| 11.10.4 | Child Labor in Operations / Supply Chain | Sourcing from operations that employ underage workers, or using subcontracting to obscure child-labor involvement. | Agriculture, fashion, mining, food |
11.11 Mass Layoffs After Profit & Disposable Workforce · 4 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.11.1 | Layoffs After Profitable Launch | Terminating large portions of teams immediately after profitable launches to avoid sharing ongoing revenue. | Gaming |
| 11.11.2 | Mass Layoffs Post-Acquisition | Implementing significant workforce reductions immediately after acquisition to improve short-term financial metrics. | Private equity |
| 11.11.3 | Layoffs to Service Debt | Cutting workforce primarily to meet debt service obligations imposed by acquisition structure. | Private equity |
| 11.11.4 | Workforce Reduction Without Transition Support | Eliminating positions without adequate severance, retraining, or job placement assistance. | Private equity |
11.12 Performance & Quality Management Abuse · 3 practices
Responsibility+ Care
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.12.1 | Performance-Review Weaponization | Using opaque performance review processes to justify predetermined attrition rather than genuine development. | Consulting |
| 11.12.2 | Credit Suppression | Failing to provide references, performance documentation, or skill verification that would help workers transition. | Staffing/temp |
| 11.12.3 | Credit / Byline Omission | Removing or omitting developer or creator credits from shipped products or published work for departing or freelance workers. | Gaming, media/journalism, music |
11.13 Pay Disparity & Discrimination · 2 practices
Responsibility+ Fairness
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.13.1 | Demographic Pay Gaps | Maintaining persistent pay disparities for women, people of color, or LGBTQ+ workers compared to peers in equivalent roles. | Film/television, internal company |
| 11.13.2 | Salary History Exploitation | Using prior salary to set compensation, perpetuating historical pay gaps. | HR/recruitment |
11.14 Moderator & Worker Trauma · 5 practices
Responsibility+ Care
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.14.1 | Moderator Mental-Health Neglect | Exposing content moderators to graphic, violent, or traumatic material without adequate support. | Social media |
| 11.14.2 | Data-Labeler Trauma | Outsourcing data labeling to workers exposed to traumatic content under poor conditions. | AI |
| 11.14.3 | Brain-Injury Concealment | Withholding or downplaying concussion diagnoses; pressuring athletes to return before recovery. | Sports/athletics, film/television (stunts) |
| 11.14.4 | Sexual-Assault Reporting Gaps | Failing to promptly report assaults to law enforcement; settling claims privately with NDAs. | Ride-hailing |
| 11.14.5 | Unsafe Working Hours | Scheduling shoots exceeding 14 hours, mandating turnaround under 8 hours. | Film/television |
11.15 Unpaid Labor & Career-Path Exploitation · 8 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.15.1 | Unpaid-Internship Abuse | Using interns as free labor on billable client work without meaningful mentorship. | PR/marketing, consulting, film/television |
| 11.15.2 | Pitch-Work Without Compensation | Requiring extensive creative work as part of competitive pitches without compensating finalists. | PR/marketing |
| 11.15.3 | Freelancer Payment Delays | Systematically delaying payment to freelance creatives, consultants, or contractors beyond contract terms. | PR/marketing, media/journalism |
| 11.15.4 | Unpaid Travel / Setup Time | Not compensating workers for travel, vehicle preparation, or job-site setup while billing clients for it. | Plumbing, home services |
| 11.15.5 | Unpaid Professional Development | Requiring caregivers to complete continuing education on their own time without compensation. | Childcare, healthcare |
| 11.15.6 | Training Cost Shifting to Worker | Requiring workers to pay for certifications or training needed for placement. | Staffing/temp |
| 11.15.7 | Crew Replacement During Strikes | Replacing striking workers with non-union or international crew to break collective bargaining. | Film/television |
| 11.15.8 | Peer-Review Free Labor | Relying on unpaid academic peer reviewers while generating substantial subscription revenue from their volunteer contributions. | Academic publishing |
11.16 Restrictions on Career Mobility · 4 practices
Responsibility+ Autonomy
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11.16.1 | Profile Data Lock-In | Preventing workers from exporting reviews, portfolios, or professional history when leaving a platform. | Freelance/gig |
| 11.16.2 | Customer-Data Hoarding from Workers | Preventing workers from accessing client contact information they need to build independent careers. | Freelance/gig, food delivery |
| 11.16.3 | Portfolio Rights Grab | Claiming ownership of employee or freelancer portfolio work beyond what is needed for delivery. | PR/marketing |
| 11.16.4 | Cross-Client Worker Profiling | Sharing worker performance data between clients to create informal blacklists. | Staffing/temp |
12.1 Predatory Pricing & Cross-Subsidy · 2 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12.1.1 | Predatory Pricing | Below-cost pricing to drive competitors out of business before raising prices. | Cross-domain (PE-funded price wars, ride-hailing vs. transit, alcohol) |
| 12.1.2 | Predatory Pricing vs. Public Infrastructure | Subsidizing services below cost to draw users from public transit or other public services, then raising prices once those alternatives are weakened. | Ride-hailing |
12.2 Acquisitions to Kill Competition · 4 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12.2.1 | Killer Acquisitions | Acquiring competitors to shutter their products, absorb talent, or prevent alternatives from reaching market. | AI, cloud/SaaS, social media |
| 12.2.2 | Industry Roll-Up to Monopoly | Systematically acquiring small competitors to create local or regional monopolies. | Private equity (dental, vet, funeral, dialysis, etc.) |
| 12.2.3 | Catalog Consolidation | Acquiring and consolidating catalogs to reduce diversity of ownership and concentrate market power. | Music industry |
| 12.2.4 | Imprint Opacity | Operating dozens of imprints under a single corporate parent while presenting them as independent. | Publishing |
12.3 Self-Preferencing on Owned Platforms · 6 practices
Responsibility+ Honesty
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12.3.1 | Buy-Box / Listing Self-Preferencing | Designing buy-box or marketplace algorithms to favor private-label products over identical or superior third-party offerings. | E-commerce |
| 12.3.2 | Cloud Self-Preferencing | Designing cloud platforms to give the provider's own SaaS or PaaS products performance, cost, or integration advantages competitors cannot replicate. | Cloud/SaaS |
| 12.3.3 | Ghost-Kitchen Data Cloning | Analyzing restaurant order data to launch competing ghost kitchens that replicate successful menu concepts. | Food delivery |
| 12.3.4 | Search Self-Preferencing | Ranking the platform's own products, services, or AI assistant content above superior third-party alternatives. | Search engines, AI platforms |
| 12.3.5 | Music Catalog Self-Preferencing | Algorithmically promoting catalog owned or controlled by the platform's parent company. | Music industry |
| 12.3.6 | Bandwidth Throttling of Competitors | Deprioritizing or degrading network traffic from competing services while favoring owned content. | Streaming, telecom |
12.4 Tying & Forced Bundling · 4 practices
Responsibility+ Autonomy
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12.4.1 | Tying Arrangements | Forcing purchase of unwanted products as a condition of obtaining the desired one. | Cloud/SaaS, agriculture (seed-herbicide), insurance |
| 12.4.2 | Default-Engine Payment for Exclusivity | Paying device manufacturers, browsers, or operating systems to set the platform as default, foreclosing competition. | Search engines |
| 12.4.3 | Search Monopoly Leverage into Adjacent Markets | Using dominant search to force adoption of complementary services. | Search engines |
| 12.4.4 | GPS Critical-Infrastructure Hostage | Leveraging society's dependence on positioning, navigation, and timing services to extract preferential terms or block redundancy. | Space/aerospace |
12.5 Exclusive Dealing & Foreclosure · 4 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12.5.1 | Price-Parity / MFN Enforcement | Contractually prohibiting sellers from offering lower prices on other platforms, inflating consumer prices. | E-commerce, hospitality |
| 12.5.2 | Spectrum / Resource Hoarding | Filing for vast spectrum allocations beyond intended use to block competitor access. | Space/aerospace, telecom |
| 12.5.3 | Launch Market Vertical Integration | Using vertical integration, exclusive pad access, or predatory pricing to prevent new entrants. | Space/aerospace |
| 12.5.4 | Independent-Bookstore Disadvantage | Negotiating exclusive terms or early-release windows with large retailers that independents cannot match. | Publishing |
12.6 Bid Rigging & Collusion · 6 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12.6.1 | Bid Suppression / Rigging | Coordinating with competitors to refrain from bidding or to submit non-competitive proposals, ensuring a predetermined winner. | Construction |
| 12.6.2 | Algorithmic Rent-Setting Coordination | Using shared data platforms to coordinate rent increases across competing landlords. | Real estate |
| 12.6.3 | Refinery Maintenance Coordination | Coordinating maintenance shutdowns to create artificial supply constraints and raise prices. | Oil/gas |
| 12.6.4 | Spoofing & Layering | Placing large orders with no intent of execution to create false impressions of supply or demand. | Crypto/blockchain, financial markets |
| 12.6.5 | Wash Trading | Executing trades between controlled accounts to create artificial volume. | Crypto/blockchain |
| 12.6.6 | Operator-Cartel Pickup-Zone Exclusion | Operator-level collusion (driver associations, not platforms) to block competitors from designated pickup zones at airports, train stations, or events, often through intimidation, vehicle blocking, or coordinated reporting to enforcement. | Taxi associations vs. rideshare drivers, airport curb monopolies |
12.7 Monopoly Rent Extraction · 7 practices
Responsibility+ Fairness
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12.7.1 | Commission / Fee Escalation | Progressively increasing platform commissions, license fees, or per-seat pricing without proportional value, exploiting switching costs. | Cloud/SaaS, food delivery, e-commerce, mobile carriers |
| 12.7.2 | Forced Advertising Participation | Making seller advertising mandatory through reduced visibility for non-participants. | E-commerce |
| 12.7.3 | Search Ranking Pay-to-Play | Requiring sellers to purchase advertising for organic search visibility, blurring ads and results. | E-commerce, food delivery |
| 12.7.4 | Forced Promotion Participation | Enrolling restaurants in discount or free-delivery campaigns without consent, with cost absorbed from margins. | Food delivery |
| 12.7.5 | Algorithmic Discovery Pay-to-Play | Requiring payment for favorable algorithmic placement, chart positioning, or editorial featuring. | Podcasting, music |
| 12.7.6 | Phone Service Monopoly in Captive Markets | Granting exclusive telecom contracts that eliminate competition. | Prison/corrections |
| 12.7.7 | Publisher Dependency Exploitation | Leveraging traffic dominance to impose unilateral terms on publishers (revenue share, format, content access). | Search engines |
12.8 Open-Source / Standards Manipulation · 9 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12.8.1 | Open-Source Bait-and-Switch | Building market position on open-source releases, then transitioning core capabilities to proprietary licenses once dominant. | AI, cloud/SaaS |
| 12.8.2 | Patent Thicket / Evergreening | Using patent thickets and litigation to block generic or biosimilar entry beyond legitimate IP protection. | Pharma/biotech |
| 12.8.3 | Pay-for-Delay | Paying generic manufacturers to delay market entry of affordable alternatives. | Pharma/biotech, healthcare |
| 12.8.4 | Public-Domain Misappropriation | Repackaging public-domain works with minor additions and claiming new copyright protection. | Publishing |
| 12.8.5 | Public-Domain Extension Lobbying | Lobbying to extend copyright terms beyond reasonable limits, restricting cultural reuse. | Music industry |
| 12.8.6 | Sample Clearance Gatekeeping | Maintaining opaque, expensive sample clearance that favors established labels and blocks independent creators. | Music industry |
| 12.8.7 | Reversion Right Obstruction | Preventing copyright reversion to creators after the statutory window through contract clauses or procedural barriers. | Music industry |
| 12.8.8 | Out-of-Print Suppression | Keeping books technically in print through token print-on-demand to prevent rights reversion. | Publishing |
| 12.8.9 | Editorial Board Replacement for Profit | Replacing dissenting editorial boards advocating for open access with compliant boards. | Academic publishing |
12.9 Merchant / Seller Exploitation · 4 practices
Responsibility+ Fairness
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 12.9.1 | Seller Data Extraction | Requiring sellers to share detailed product, pricing, and sales data that the platform then uses to compete against them. | E-commerce |
| 12.9.2 | Restaurant Customer-Data Hoarding | Preventing restaurants from accessing customer data for orders placed through the platform. | Food delivery |
| 12.9.3 | Supplier Squeeze | Using market power to impose below-sustainability prices on farmers, suppliers, or smaller producers. | Grocery, food/beverage manufacturing |
| 12.9.4 | Subcontractor Non-Payment | Withholding or delaying subcontractor payments to improve cash flow, using retainage as leverage. | Construction |
13.1 Supply Chain Opacity · 7 practices
Responsibility+ Honesty
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 13.1.1 | Supply Chain Opacity | Constructing complex multi-tier supply chains with insufficient documentation, making it impossible to trace inputs from origin to consumer. | Seafood, fashion, agriculture, beauty, cannabis, food/beverage manufacturing |
| 13.1.2 | Subcontractor Concealment | Hiding unauthorized subcontracting where workers face the worst conditions, claiming visibility only to Tier 1 suppliers. | Fashion |
| 13.1.3 | Audit Theater | Conducting pre-announced audits that allow temporary remediation, without follow-up or worker-driven monitoring. | Fashion, food, beauty |
| 13.1.4 | Unannounced Carrier Substitution | Handing shipments to undisclosed subcontractors with different service or liability standards. | Shipping/freight |
| 13.1.5 | Transshipment Concealment | Transferring catch or goods at sea between vessels to mix legal and illegal sources, obscuring origins. | Seafood |
| 13.1.6 | Vessel-Tracking Avoidance | Disabling, tampering with, or failing to install AIS or VMS tracking to evade monitoring. | Seafood |
| 13.1.7 | Quota Shell Games | Transferring quotas between vessels, regions, or corporate entities to obscure true catch and evade limits. | Seafood |
13.2 Forced & Child Labor in Supply Chain · 9 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 13.2.1 | Forced-Labor Sourcing | Procuring inputs from regions or operations with documented forced labor. | Fashion (cotton), seafood, agriculture, food/beverage manufacturing |
| 13.2.2 | Child-Labor Sourcing | Sourcing from suppliers that employ underage workers or using subcontracting structures to obscure child labor. | Agriculture, fashion, mining (rare earth, cobalt), food |
| 13.2.3 | Conflict-Mineral Sourcing | Failing to audit or disclose conflict-mineral sourcing despite known links to violence and human rights abuses. | Internal company ethics (hardware), electronics, automotive |
| 13.2.4 | Migrant-Recruitment Brokers | Hiring through labor brokers who charge recruitment fees, withhold wages, or impose contracts that create indebtedness. | Seafood, agriculture, construction |
| 13.2.5 | Cobalt / Lithium Source Opacity | Purchasing battery materials without tracing origin or verifying compliance with labor and environmental standards. | Renewable energy, electronics |
| 13.2.6 | Rare-Earth Mining Abuse | Sourcing from mines with documented child labor, forced labor, or toxic environmental practices. | Renewable energy, electronics |
| 13.2.7 | Panel-Manufacturing Labor Conditions | Procuring from factories with unsafe conditions, excessive hours, or wage theft. | Renewable energy |
| 13.2.8 | Audit-Scope Restriction | Limiting audit scope, providing advance notice, or selecting auditors with conflicts of interest to undermine ethical-sourcing claims. | Renewable energy |
| 13.2.9 | At-Sea Worker Abuse Concealment | Tolerating physical violence, food withholding, or confinement of crew far from oversight. | Seafood |
13.3 Animal Cruelty in Supply Chain · 4 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 13.3.1 | Wildlife-Exploitation Tours | Selling animal-encounter experiences (elephant rides, dolphin swims, tiger photos) sourced from abusive facilities. | Travel/tourism |
| 13.3.2 | Puppy-Mill Concealment | Sourcing from high-volume commercial breeders while marketing animals as ethically bred. | Pet industry |
| 13.3.3 | Foie Gras / Factory-Farm Sourcing | Sourcing from intensive operations without disclosure of conditions; opposing welfare regulation. | Food, restaurants |
| 13.3.4 | Antibiotic Overuse in Livestock | Administering antibiotics prophylactically at scale to compensate for crowded conditions, accelerating resistance. | Agriculture |
13.4 Counterfeit & Sanctioned Goods · 4 practices
Responsibility+ Honesty
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 13.4.1 | Counterfeit Goods Tolerance | Failing to police third-party listings for counterfeits while profiting from listing fees and traffic. | E-commerce, fashion |
| 13.4.2 | Sanctions Circumvention | Providing services to individuals, entities, or jurisdictions under sanctions, exploiting pseudonymity to bypass compliance. | Crypto/blockchain |
| 13.4.3 | Mixing Service Money Laundering | Operating or promoting mixing services that obscure transaction origins to facilitate laundering. | Crypto/blockchain |
| 13.4.4 | Restricted-Substance Export to Weak-Regulation Markets | Exporting chemicals banned in producing nations to countries with weaker frameworks. | Chemical manufacturing, tobacco |
13.5 Deforestation-Linked Sourcing · 2 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 13.5.1 | Deforestation-Linked Inputs | Sourcing palm oil, soy, cocoa, beef, or paper from suppliers linked to illegal or unsustainable deforestation without traceability. | Food/beverage manufacturing, beauty (palm oil), agriculture |
| 13.5.2 | Deforestation for Farmland | Clearing forested or ecologically significant land for agricultural expansion without environmental review. | Agriculture |
13.6 Supplier Squeeze & Contract Abuse · 3 practices
Responsibility+ Fairness
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 13.6.1 | Below-Sustainability Pricing on Suppliers | Imposing prices on farmers or raw-material suppliers that drive labor abuse and environmental shortcuts. | Food manufacturing, grocery, fashion |
| 13.6.2 | Contract Farming Exploitation | Imposing one-sided contracts that transfer production risk to farmers while locking in below-market purchase prices. | Agriculture |
| 13.6.3 | Unfair Trade Practices | Bypassing fair-trade premiums, reneging on contracts, or imposing unilateral price changes on smallholder producers. | Food manufacturing |
14.1 Emission Underreporting & Concealment · 8 practices
Responsibility+ Honesty
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14.1.1 | Emission Underreporting | Understating Scope 1, 2, or 3 emissions through selective measurement, offset double-counting, or excluded segments. | Logistics, shipping, oil/gas, mining, energy utilities, waste management |
| 14.1.2 | Methane Emission Underreporting | Systematically underreporting methane through selective measurement or accounting. | Oil/gas, waste management |
| 14.1.3 | Toxic Release Underreporting | Systematically underreporting toxic releases to TRI or equivalent reporting systems. | Chemical manufacturing |
| 14.1.4 | Air Quality Monitoring Avoidance | Locating fenceline monitors to avoid detection or disabling monitors during peak release periods. | Chemical manufacturing |
| 14.1.5 | Compute Energy Concealment | Failing to disclose energy, water, or carbon costs of training and operating large AI models. | AI |
| 14.1.6 | Programmatic Ad Carbon Footprint | Operating massive computational infrastructure for real-time bidding without accounting for the resulting energy waste. | Digital advertising |
| 14.1.7 | Launch Emission Non-Disclosure | Failing to measure, report, or disclose atmospheric impact of launch emissions, including alumina, soot, and ozone-depleting compounds. | Space/aerospace |
| 14.1.8 | Reentry Risk to Populated Areas | Planning uncontrolled or marginally controlled reentry trajectories without adequate notification. | Space/aerospace |
14.2 Carbon-Offset Greenwashing · 5 practices
Responsibility+ Honesty
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14.2.1 | Carbon-Offset Greenwashing | Claiming carbon neutrality through low-quality, non-additional, or unverifiable offsets while absolute emissions rise. | AI, crypto, airlines, oil/gas, logistics, shipping, travel, renewable energy |
| 14.2.2 | REC Double-Counting | Counting the same renewable certificates toward both regulatory compliance and voluntary customer claims. | Renewable energy, energy utilities, crypto |
| 14.2.3 | Renewable Without Additionality | Claiming renewable operations while purchasing existing renewable credits rather than funding new capacity. | Crypto/blockchain |
| 14.2.4 | Carbon-Credit Misrepresentation | Selling carbon credits from landfill gas or other capture that does not represent genuine additional reduction. | Waste management |
| 14.2.5 | Curtailment Concealment | Failing to disclose when renewable generation is curtailed, overstating actual clean energy delivered. | Renewable energy |
14.3 Pollution Concealment · 10 practices
Responsibility+ Honesty
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14.3.1 | Groundwater Contamination Concealment | Detecting but not disclosing chemical migration into groundwater used for drinking, agriculture, or ecosystems. | Chemical manufacturing, oil/gas, agriculture, mining |
| 14.3.2 | Sewer/Water Overflow Concealment | Failing to report combined sewer overflows that release raw sewage into waterways. | Water utilities |
| 14.3.3 | Acid Mine Drainage Neglect | Failing to prevent or treat acid drainage that contaminates waterways for decades. | Mining |
| 14.3.4 | Pesticide Drift onto Communities | Applying broad-acre or aerial pesticides in conditions causing drift onto neighboring communities, schools, or organic farms. | Agriculture, pest control |
| 14.3.5 | Fertilizer-Runoff Concealment | Concealing the extent of nutrient pollution (dead zones, algal blooms, groundwater contamination). | Agriculture |
| 14.3.6 | Spill Response Delay | Delaying containment, cleanup, or notification after spills to minimize perceived liability. | Oil/gas, chemical manufacturing |
| 14.3.7 | Test-Frequency Reduction | Reducing water-quality testing frequency to cut costs, particularly in low-income service areas. | Water utilities |
| 14.3.8 | PFAS Concealment | Failing to test for or disclose PFAS in drinking water or in products. | Water utilities, personal care, chemical manufacturing |
| 14.3.9 | Contamination Notice Delay | Delaying public notification of water-quality violations. | Water utilities |
| 14.3.10 | Ground Water Contamination From Testing | Allowing propellant, solvent, or chemical runoff to contaminate aquifers without remediation. | Space/aerospace |
14.4 Environmental Justice Siting · 3 practices
Responsibility+ Fairness
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14.4.1 | Polluting-Facility Siting in Vulnerable Communities | Concentrating new infrastructure (power plants, substations, pipelines, transfer stations, landfills) in low-income or minority communities. | Energy utilities, waste management, public transit, oil/gas |
| 14.4.2 | Diesel Bus Retention in Polluted Areas | Continuing to operate diesel buses in already-burdened communities while electrifying affluent routes. | Public transit |
| 14.4.3 | NIMBY Exploitation | Siting renewable or other projects in low-income or minority communities to avoid affluent opposition. | Renewable energy |
14.5 Habitat & Ecosystem Destruction · 9 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14.5.1 | Habitat Destruction Underreporting | Minimizing the scope of ecological impact in environmental assessments to secure permits. | Mining |
| 14.5.2 | Biodiversity Monoculture Push | Promoting or enforcing single-crop systems that destroy pollinator habitats and erode genetic diversity. | Agriculture |
| 14.5.3 | Bottom Trawling on Sensitive Habitats | Deploying bottom trawl gear in coral, sponge beds, or seamounts, causing irreversible damage. | Seafood |
| 14.5.4 | Marine Protected Area Incursion | Fishing within designated MPAs or no-take zones through boundary ambiguity or weak enforcement. | Seafood |
| 14.5.5 | Coral Reef Damage Concealment | Promoting reef activities (sunscreen, anchoring, trampling) without disclosing impact. | Travel/tourism |
| 14.5.6 | Bycatch Non-Disclosure | Failing to report or disclose non-target species killed during fishing operations. | Seafood |
| 14.5.7 | Endangered-Species Mislabeling | Selling endangered species under common or mislabeled names to circumvent awareness and trade protections. | Seafood |
| 14.5.8 | Pollinator Impact Disregard | Using neonicotinoid or other pollinator-toxic chemicals without risk assessment or mitigation. | Pest control, agriculture |
| 14.5.9 | Megaconstellation Astronomy Interference | Deploying reflective satellites that degrade ground- and space-based astronomy without meaningful mitigation. | Space/aerospace |
14.6 Microplastics & Persistent Pollutants · 6 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14.6.1 | Microplastic Ingredients | Formulating with microbeads, glitter, or synthetic polymers that enter waterways despite known damage. | Beauty, personal care |
| 14.6.2 | Microplastic Pollution Concealment | Failing to disclose synthetic-fabric shedding or opposing labeling requirements about microplastic release. | Fashion |
| 14.6.3 | Microplastic from Fishing Gear (Ghost Gear) | Abandoning, losing, or discarding gear that degrades into microplastics and continues entangling marine life. | Seafood |
| 14.6.4 | PFAS Forever Chemicals | Continuing to manufacture PFAS or substituting structurally similar analogs while marketing PFAS-free. | Chemical manufacturing, personal care |
| 14.6.5 | BPA Replacement With Equally Harmful Alternatives | Substituting bisphenol-A with structurally similar bisphenol analogs that carry equivalent endocrine-disrupting properties. | Chemical manufacturing |
| 14.6.6 | Microplastic in Children's Feeding Products | Manufacturing bottles, utensils, or plates from materials that shed microplastics during normal use. | Baby/children's products |
14.7 E-Waste & Disposal · 8 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14.7.1 | Designed-In E-Waste | Designing products that are difficult to disassemble, recycle, or dispose of responsibly. | Home appliances, electronics |
| 14.7.2 | AI Hardware Churn | Cycling through GPU and accelerator hardware at rapid pace without responsible recycling or lifecycle planning. | AI |
| 14.7.3 | Mining Hardware E-Waste | Generating e-waste through short-lived ASIC mining hardware without producer responsibility. | Crypto/blockchain |
| 14.7.4 | Recycling Greenwashing | Reporting recycling rates that include waste sent to facilities that subsequently landfill it; marketing zero-waste claims without verification. | Waste management, fashion, beauty |
| 14.7.5 | Returns Disposal | Routing returned goods to landfill or incineration rather than resale, donation, or recycling when reuse is feasible. | Logistics, e-commerce |
| 14.7.6 | Solar Panel End-of-Life Failure | Failing to plan for or fund recycling and safe disposal of decommissioned panels, blades, or batteries. | Renewable energy |
| 14.7.7 | Non-Recyclable Material Selection | Choosing composite or non-recyclable materials when recyclable alternatives exist at comparable cost. | Home appliances |
| 14.7.8 | Packaging Excess | Using oversized or non-recyclable packaging that generates unnecessary waste. | Home appliances, beauty, e-commerce |
14.8 Pesticide & Antibiotic Overuse · 4 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14.8.1 | Pesticide Application Beyond Label | Applying chemicals at concentrations, frequencies, or locations exceeding label specifications. | Pest control |
| 14.8.2 | Restricted-Use Chemicals to Uncertified Applicators | Making restricted-use pesticides available outside proper licensing. | Pest control |
| 14.8.3 | IPM Avoidance | Defaulting to chemical treatment instead of Integrated Pest Management approaches that minimize pesticide use. | Pest control |
| 14.8.4 | Antibiotic Overprescription in Veterinary | Prescribing antibiotics without proper diagnostics, contributing to resistance. | Veterinary, agriculture |
14.9 Site Abandonment & Stranded Liabilities · 6 practices
Responsibility+ Accountability
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14.9.1 | Site Abandonment Without Remediation | Decommissioning wells, mines, or facilities without adequate remediation, leaving costs to public entities. | Oil/gas, mining |
| 14.9.2 | Reclamation Bond Underfunding | Posting insufficient reclamation bonds, leaving taxpayers liable for cleanup. | Mining |
| 14.9.3 | Stranded Asset Concealment | Failing to disclose climate-related financial risks and asset stranding in financial reporting. | Oil/gas |
| 14.9.4 | Superfund Cleanup Delay | Using litigation or jurisdictional arguments to delay or reduce remediation obligations. | Chemical manufacturing |
| 14.9.5 | End-of-Life Orbital Disposal Failure | Failing to deorbit defunct satellites within committed timelines, leaving derelict objects as collision hazards. | Space/aerospace |
| 14.9.6 | Megaconstellation Debris Risk | Deploying large constellations without adequate debris-mitigation planning. | Space/aerospace |
14.10 Catastrophic Risk Concealment · 5 practices
Responsibility+ Safety
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14.10.1 | Tailings Dam Risk Concealment | Understating structural risk of tailings dams to avoid costly upgrades or closure. | Mining |
| 14.10.2 | Accident & Near-Miss Concealment | Suppressing reports of chemical releases, fires, explosions, or near-miss events that could have been catastrophic. | Chemical manufacturing |
| 14.10.3 | Community Notification Failure | Failing to inform surrounding communities about chemical hazards or release events in a timely manner. | Chemical manufacturing |
| 14.10.4 | Battery / Storage Risk Opacity | Underreporting or downplaying battery fire risks or thermal-runaway incidents at storage facilities. | Renewable energy |
| 14.10.5 | Conjunction-Data Opacity | Withholding satellite conjunction data, refusing to coordinate maneuvers, or concealing near-miss events. | Space/aerospace |
14.11 Lobbying Against Environmental Regulation · 7 practices
Responsibility+ Accountability
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14.11.1 | Climate Policy Obstruction | Funding or directing lobbying to obstruct, weaken, or delay climate legislation while publicly claiming climate commitment. | Oil/gas, energy utilities |
| 14.11.2 | Chemical Regulation Lobbying | Funding campaigns to weaken, delay, or repeal chemical safety legislation including TSCA reforms. | Chemical manufacturing |
| 14.11.3 | Anti-Distributed-Generation Lobbying | Funding opposition to rooftop solar, battery storage, or net-metering policies. | Energy utilities |
| 14.11.4 | Preemption Strategy | Supporting federal legislation that preempts stronger state-level chemical or environmental regulation. | Chemical manufacturing |
| 14.11.5 | Subsidy Reliance With Record Profits | Accepting subsidies and tax breaks while distributing record shareholder returns and resisting fiscal reform. | Oil/gas |
| 14.11.6 | GMO Labeling Opposition | Lobbying against mandatory labeling or transparency requirements for genetically modified ingredients. | Agriculture |
| 14.11.7 | Smart-Gun Technology Opposition | Actively lobbying against or refusing to develop personalized firearm technology that prevents unauthorized use. | Firearms |
14.12 Resource Hoarding · 3 practices
Responsibility
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14.12.1 | Water Rights Exploitation | Diverting or hoarding water beyond sustainable needs, depleting community supplies in drought-prone regions. | Agriculture, food/beverage manufacturing, oil/gas, mining |
| 14.12.2 | Soil Degradation Concealment | Continuing intensive monoculture practices known to degrade topsoil while promoting sustainability. | Agriculture |
| 14.12.3 | Agricultural Land Displacement for Energy | Converting productive farmland to solar or wind installations without food-security assessment. | Renewable energy |
15.1 Whistleblower Suppression · 4 practices
Responsibility+ Accountability
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 15.1.1 | Whistleblower Retaliation | Demoting, terminating, blacklisting, or otherwise retaliating against employees who report fraud, safety failures, or unethical practices. | Internal company ethics, defense, government, mining, accounting, healthcare, pharma, nonprofits, accounting, oil/gas |
| 15.1.2 | NDAs Hiding Public Harm | Using NDAs to suppress information about environmental, health, or safety risks the public has a right to know. | PR/marketing, pharma/biotech, automotive (defects), film/television |
| 15.1.3 | Hush Settlements | Settling individual claims under NDAs that prevent broader disclosure of misconduct or hazards. | Cross-domain |
| 15.1.4 | Inspector General Understaffing | Underfunding oversight offices to render them ineffective, then citing "no findings" as evidence of compliance. | Government services |
15.9 Strategic Bankruptcy & Corporate Restructuring · 4 practices
Responsibility+ Accountability
| § | Practice | Description | Seen in |
|---|---|---|---|
| 15.9.1 | Warranty Evasion Through Restructuring | Using corporate restructuring, shell entities, or vague contract language to avoid honoring warranties. | Construction |
| 15.9.2 | Project Abandonment | Walking away from projects after receiving substantial payments, leaving owners with unfinished structures and no recourse. | Construction |
| 15.9.3 | Corporate-Structure Opacity | Operating through shell companies or complex ownership to obscure surveillance product origins or other liabilities. | Surveillance technology |
| 15.9.4 | Government Contract Opacity for Surveillance | Classifying or concealing surveillance contracts to prevent public awareness. | Surveillance technology |